Esterases receive special attention because their wide distribution in biological systems and environments and their importance for physiology and chemical synthesis. The prediction of esterases substrate promiscuity level from sequence data and the molecular reasons why certain such enzymes are more promiscuous than others, remain to be elucidated. This limits the surveillance of the sequence space for esterases potentially leading to new versatile biocatalysts and new insights into their role in cellular function. Here we performed an extensive analysis of the substrate spectra of 145 phylogenetically and environmentally diverse microbial esterases, when tested with 96 diverse esters. We determined the primary factors shaping their substrate range by analyzing substrate range patterns in combination with structural analysis and protein-ligand simulations. We found a structural parameter that helps ranking (classifying) promiscuity level of esterases from sequence data at 94% accuracy. This parameter, the active site effective volume, exemplifies the topology of the catalytic environment by measuring the active site cavity volume corrected by the relative solvent accessible surface area (SASA) of the catalytic triad. Sequences encoding esterases with active site effective volumes (cavity volume/SASA) above a threshold show greater substrate spectra, which can be further extended in combination with phylogenetic data. This measure provides also a valuable tool for interrogating substrates capable of being converted. This measure, found to be transferred to phosphatases of the haloalkanoic acid dehalogenase superfamily and possibly other enzymatic systems, represents a powerful tool for low-cost bioprospecting for esterases with broad substrate ranges, in large scale sequence datasets.
Title: Non-lipolytic and lipolytic sequence-related carboxylesterases: a comparative study of the structure-function relationships of rabbit liver esterase 1 and bovine pancreatic bile-salt-activated lipase Chahinian H, Fantini J, Garmy N, Manco G, Sarda L Ref: Biochimica & Biophysica Acta, 1801:1195, 2010 : PubMed
To differentiate esterases from lipases at the structure-function level, we have compared the kinetic properties and structural features of sequence-related esterase 1 from rabbit liver (rLE) and bile-salt-activated lipase from bovine pancreas (bBAL). In contrast to rLE, bBAL hydrolyses water-insoluble medium and long chain esters as vinyl laurate, trioctanoin and olive oil. Conversely, rLE and bBAL are both active on water-soluble short chain esters as vinyl acetate, vinyl propionate, vinyl butyrate, tripropionin, tributyrin and p-nitrophenyl butyrate. However, the enzymes show distinctive kinetic behaviours. rLE displays maximal activity at low substrate concentration, below the critical micelle concentration, whereas bBAL acts preferencially on emulsified esters, at concentration exceeding the solubility limit. Comparison of the 3D structures of rLE and bBAL shows, in particular, that the peptide loop at positions 116-123 in bBAL is deleted in rLE. This peptide segment interacts with a bile salt molecule thus inducing a conformational transition which gives access to the active site. Inhibition studies and manual docking of a bulky ester molecule as vinyl laurate in the catalytic pocket of rLE and bBAL show that the inability of the esterase to hydrolyse large water-insoluble esters is not due to steric hindrance. It is hypothesized that esterases lack specific hydrophobic structures involved both in the stabilization of the lipase-lipid adsorption complex at interfaces and in the spontaneous transfer of a single substrate molecule from interface to the catalytic site.
Gastric lipase is active under acidic conditions and shows optimum activity on insoluble triglycerides at pH 4. The present results show that gastric lipase also acts in solution on vinyl butyrate, with an optimum activity above pH 7, which suggests that gastric lipase is able to hydrolyze ester bonds via the classical mechanism of serine hydrolases. These results support previous structural studies in which the catalytic triad of gastric lipase was reported to show no specific features. The optimum activity of gastric lipase shifted toward lower pH values, however, when the vinyl butyrate concentration was greater than the solubility limit. Experiments performed with long-chain triglycerides showed that gastric lipase binds optimally to the oil-water interface at low pH values. To study the effects of the pH on the adsorption step independently from substrate hydrolysis, gastric lipase adsorption on solid hydrophobic surfaces was monitored by total internal reflection fluorescence (TIRF), as well as using a quartz crystal microbalance. Both techniques showed a pH-dependent reversible gastric lipase adsorption process, which was optimum at pH 5 (Kd = 6.5 nM). Lipase adsorption and desorption constants (ka = 147,860 M(-1) s(-1) and kd = 139 x 10(-4) s(-1) at pH 6) were estimated from TIRF experiments. These results indicate that the optimum activity of gastric lipase at acidic pH is only "apparent" and results from the fact that lipase adsorption at lipid-water interfaces is the pH-dependent limiting step in the overall process of insoluble substrate hydrolysis. This specific kinetic feature of interfacial enzymology should be taken into account when studying any soluble enzyme acting on an insoluble substrate.
