Title: Direct correlation between molecular dynamics and enzymatic stability: a comparative neutron scattering study of native human butyrylcholinesterase and its aged soman conjugate Gabel F, Masson P, Froment MT, Doctor BP, Saxena A, Silman I, Zaccai G, Weik M Ref: Biophysical Journal, 96:1489, 2009 : PubMed
An incoherent elastic neutron scattering study of the molecular dynamics of native human butyrylcholinesterase and its "aged" soman-inhibited conjugate revealed a significant change in molecular flexibility on an angstrom-nanosecond scale as a function of temperature. The results were related to the stability of each state as established previously by differential scanning calorimetry. A striking relationship was found between the denaturation behavior and the molecular flexibility of the native and inhibited enzymes as a function of temperature. This was reflected in a quantitative correlation between the atomic mean-square displacements on an angstrom-nanosecond scale determined by neutron spectroscopy and the calorimetric specific heat. By the application of a simple two-state model that describes the transition from a folded to a denatured state, the denaturation temperatures of the native and the inhibited enzyme were correctly extracted from the atomic mean-square displacements. Furthermore, the transition entropy and enthalpy extracted from the model fit of the neutron data were, within the experimental accuracy, compatible with the values determined by differential scanning calorimetry.
Acetylcholinesterase plays a crucial role in nerve-impulse transmission at cholinergic synapses. The apparent paradox that it displays high turnover despite its active site being buried raises cogent questions as to how the traffic of substrates and products to and from the active site can occur so rapidly in such circumstances. Here, a kinetic crystallography strategy aimed at structurally addressing the issue of product traffic in acetylcholinesterase is presented, in which UV-laser-induced cleavage of a photolabile precursor of the enzymatic product analogue arsenocholine, 'caged' arsenocholine, is performed in a temperature-controlled X-ray crystallography regime. The 'caged' arsenocholine was shown to bind at both the active and peripheral sites of acetylcholinesterase. UV irradiation of a complex with acetylcholinesterase during a brief temperature excursion from 100 K to room temperature is most likely to have resulted in a decrease in occupancy by the caged compound. Microspectrophotometric experiments showed that the caged compound had indeed been photocleaved. It is proposed that a fraction of the arsenocholine molecules released within the crystal had been expelled from both the active and the peripheral sites. Partial q-weighted difference refinement revealed a relative movement of the two domains in acetylcholinesterase after photolysis and the room-temperature excursion, resulting in an increase in the active-site gorge volume of 30% and 35% in monomers A and B of the asymmetric unit, respectively. Moreover, an alternative route to the active-site gorge of the enzyme appeared to open. This structural characterization of acetylcholinesterase 'at work' is consistent with the idea that choline exits from the enzyme after catalysis either via the gorge or via an alternative 'backdoor' trajectory.
Acetylcholinesterase (AChE) terminates nerve-impulse transmission at cholinergic synapses by rapid hydrolysis of the neurotransmitter, acetylcholine. Substrate traffic in AChE involves at least two binding sites, the catalytic and peripheral anionic sites, which have been suggested to be allosterically related and involved in substrate inhibition. Here, we present the crystal structures of Torpedo californica AChE complexed with the substrate acetylthiocholine, the product thiocholine and a nonhydrolysable substrate analogue. These structures provide a series of static snapshots of the substrate en route to the active site and identify, for the first time, binding of substrate and product at both the peripheral and active sites. Furthermore, they provide structural insight into substrate inhibition in AChE at two different substrate concentrations. Our structural data indicate that substrate inhibition at moderate substrate concentration is due to choline exit being hindered by a substrate molecule bound at the peripheral site. At the higher concentration, substrate inhibition arises from prevention of exit of acetate due to binding of two substrate molecules within the active-site gorge.
Incoherent elastic neutron scattering experiments on members of the cholinesterase family were carried out to investigate how molecular dynamics is affected by covalent inhibitor binding and by differences in primary and quaternary structure. Tetrameric native and soman-inhibited human butyrylcholinesterase (HuBChE) as well as native dimeric Drosophila melanogaster acetylcholinesterase (DmAChE) hydrated protein powders were examined. Atomic mean-square displacements (MSDs) were found to be identical for native HuBChE and for DmAChE in the whole temperature range examined, leading to the conclusion that differences in activity and substrate specificity are not reflected by a global modification of subnanosecond molecular dynamics. MSDs of native and soman-inhibited HuBChE were identical below the thermal denaturation temperature of the native enzyme, indicating a common mean free-energy surface. Denaturation of the native enzyme is reflected by a relative increase of MSDs consistent with entropic stabilization of the unfolded state. The results suggest that the stabilization of HuBChE phosphorylated by soman is due to an increase in free energy of the unfolded state due to a decrease in entropy.
Title: Poster (74) Structural studies on torpedo californica acetylcholinesterase in complex with a substrate analogue Colletier JP, Fournier D, Greenblatt HM, Sussman JL, Zaccai G, Silman I, Weik M Ref: In: Cholinesterases in the Second Millennium: Biomolecular and Pathological Aspects, (Inestrosa NC, Campos EO) P. Universidad Catolica de Chile-FONDAP Biomedicina:359, 2004 : PubMed
A major result of incoherent elastic neutron-scattering experiments on protein powders is the strong dependence of the intramolecular dynamics on the sample environment. We performed a series of incoherent elastic neutron-scattering experiments on lyophilized human butyrylcholinesterase (HuBChE) powders under different conditions (solvent composition and hydration degree) in the temperature range from 20 to 285 K to elucidate the effect of the environment on the enzyme atomic mean-square displacements. Comparing D(2)O- with H(2)O-hydrated samples, we were able to investigate protein as well as hydration water molecular dynamics. HuBChE lyophilized from three distinct buffers showed completely different atomic mean-square displacements at temperatures above approximately 200 K: a salt-free sample and a sample containing Tris-HCl showed identical small-amplitude motions. A third sample, containing sodium phosphate, displayed highly reduced mean-square displacements at ambient temperature with respect to the other two samples. Below 200 K, all samples displayed similar mean-square displacements. We draw the conclusion that the reduction of intramolecular protein mean-square displacements on an Angstrom-nanosecond scale by the solvent depends not only on the presence of salt ions but also on their type.
