Spilling Christopher DDepartment of Chemistry and Biochemistry and the Center for Nanoscience, University of Missouri-St. Louis, One University Boulevard, St. Louis, MO 63121 USAPhone : Fax : Send E-Mail to Spilling Christopher D
A hallmark of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M. tb), the aetiologic agent of tuberculosis, is its ability to metabolise host-derived lipids. However, the enzymes and mechanisms underlying such metabolism are still largely unknown. We previously reported that the Cyclophostin & Cyclipostins (CyC) analogues, a new family of potent antimycobacterial molecules, react specifically and covalently with (Ser/Cys)-based enzymes mostly involved in bacterial lipid metabolism. Here, we report the synthesis of new CyC alkyne-containing inhibitors (CyC(yne) ) and their use for the direct fishing of target proteins in M. tb culture via bio-orthogonal click-chemistry activity-based protein profiling (CC-ABPP). This approach led to the capture and identification of a variety of enzymes, and many of them involved in lipid or steroid metabolisms. One of the captured enzymes, HsaD (Rv3569c), is required for the survival of M. tb within macrophages and is thus a potential therapeutic target. This prompted us to further explore and validate, through a combination of biochemical and structural approaches, the specificity of HsaD inhibition by the CyC analogues. We confirmed that the CyC bind covalently to the catalytic Ser(114) residue, leading to a total loss of enzyme activity. These data were supported by the X-ray structures of four HsaD-CyC complexes, obtained at resolutions between 1.6 and 2.6 . The identification of mycobacterial enzymes directly captured by the CyC(yne) probes through CC-ABPP paves the way to better understand and potentially target key players at crucial stages of the bacilli life cycle.
Tuberculosis (TB) caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M. tb) still remains the deadliest infectious disease worldwide with 1.5 million deaths in 2018, of which about 15% are attributed to resistant strains. Another significant example is Mycobacterium abscessus (M. abscessus), a nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM) responsible for cutaneous and pulmonary infections, representing up to 95% of NTM infections in cystic fibrosis (CF) patients. M. abscessus is a new clinically relevant pathogen and is considered one of the most drug-resistant mycobacteria for which standardized chemotherapeutic regimens are still lacking. Together the emergence of M. tb and M. abscessus multi-drug resistant strains with ineffective and expensive therapeutics, have paved the way to the development of new classes of anti-mycobacterial agents offering additional therapeutic options. In this context, specific inhibitors of mycobacterial lipolytic enzymes represent novel and promising antibacterial molecules to address this challenging issue. The results highlighted here include a complete overview of the antibacterial activities, either in broth medium or inside infected macrophages, of two families of promising and potent anti-mycobacterial multi-target agents, i.e. oxadiazolone-core compounds (OX) and Cyclophostin & Cyclipostins analogs (CyC); the identification and biochemical validation of their effective targets (e.g., the antigen 85 complex and TesA playing key roles in mycolic acid metabolism) together with their respective crystal structures. To our knowledge, these are the first families of compounds able to target and impair replicating as well as intracellular bacteria. We are still impelled in deciphering their mode of action and finding new potential therapeutic targets against mycobacterial-related diseases.
The progression of mycobacterial diseases requires the development of new therapeutics. This study evaluated the efficacy and selectivity of a panel of Cyclophostin and Cyclipostins analogues (CyCs) against various bacteria and mycobacteria. The activity 26 CyCs was first assayed by the agar plate method. Compounds exhibiting 50-100% growth inhibition were then selected to determine their minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) by the resazurin microtiter assay (REMA). The best drug candidate was further tested against clinical mycobacterial isolates and bacteria responsible for nosocomial infections, including 6 Gram-negative bacteria, 5 Gram-positive bacteria, 29 rapid-growing mycobacteria belonging to the Mycobacterium chelonae-abscessus clade and 3 slow-growing mycobacteria (Mycobacterium marinum, Mycobacterium bovis BCG and Mycobacterium tuberculosis). Among the 26 CyCs tested, 10 were active and their inhibitory activity was exclusively restricted to mycobacteria. The best candidate (CyC17) was further tested against 26 clinical strains and showed high selectivity for mycobacteria, with MICs (<2-40 microg/mL) comparable with those of most classical antimicrobials used to treat M. abscessus infections. Together, these results support the fact that such CyCs represent a new family of potent and selective inhibitors against mycobacteria. This is of particular interest for future chemotherapeutic developments against mycobacterial-associated infections, especially against M. abscessus, the most drug-resistant mycobacterial species.
With the high number of patients infected by tuberculosis and the sharp increase of drug-resistant tuberculosis cases, developing new drugs to fight this disease has become increasingly urgent. In this context, analogs of the naturally occurring enolphosphates Cyclipostins and Cyclophostin (CyC analogs) offer new therapeutic opportunities. The CyC analogs display potent activity both in vitro and in infected macrophages against several pathogenic mycobacteria including Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Mycobacterium abscessus. Interestingly, these CyC inhibitors target several enzymes with active-site serine or cysteine residues that play key roles in mycobacterial lipid and cell wall metabolism. Among them, TesA, a putative thioesterase involved in the synthesis of phthiocerol dimycocerosates (PDIMs) and phenolic glycolipids (PGLs), has been identified. These two lipids (PDIM and PGL) are non-covalently bound to the outer cell wall in several human pathogenic mycobacteria and are important virulence factors. Herein, we used biochemical and structural approaches to validate TesA as an effective pharmacological target of the CyC analogs. We confirmed both thioesterase and esterase activities of TesA, and showed that the most active inhibitor CyC17 binds covalently to the catalytic Ser104 residue leading to a total loss of enzyme activity. These data were supported by the X-ray structure, obtained at a 2.6-A resolution, of a complex in which CyC17 is bound to TesA. Our study provides evidence that CyC17 inhibits the activity of TesA, thus paving the way to a new strategy for impairing the PDIM and PGL biosynthesis, potentially decreasing the virulence of associated mycobacterial species.
An increasing prevalence of cases of drug-resistant tuberculosis requires the development of more efficacious chemotherapies. We previously reported the discovery of a new class of cyclipostins and cyclophostin (CyC) analogs exhibiting potent activity against Mycobacterium tuberculosis both in vitro and in infected macrophages. Competitive labeling/enrichment assays combined with MS have identified several serine or cysteine enzymes in lipid and cell wall metabolism as putative targets of these CyC compounds. These targets included members of the antigen 85 (Ag85) complex (i.e. Ag85A, Ag85B, and Ag85C), responsible for biosynthesis of trehalose dimycolate and mycolylation of arabinogalactan. Herein, we used biochemical and structural approaches to validate the Ag85 complex as a pharmacological target of the CyC analogs. We found that CyC7beta, CyC8beta, and CyC17 bind covalently to the catalytic Ser(124) residue in Ag85C; inhibit mycolyltransferase activity (i.e. the transfer of a fatty acid molecule onto trehalose); and reduce triacylglycerol synthase activity, a property previously attributed to Ag85A. Supporting these results, an X-ray structure of Ag85C in complex with CyC8beta disclosed that this inhibitor occupies Ag85C's substrate-binding pocket. Importantly, metabolic labeling of M. tuberculosis cultures revealed that the CyC compounds impair both trehalose dimycolate synthesis and mycolylation of arabinogalactan. Overall, our study provides compelling evidence that CyC analogs can inhibit the activity of the Ag85 complex in vitro and in mycobacteria, opening the door to a new strategy for inhibiting Ag85. The high-resolution crystal structure obtained will further guide the rational optimization of new CyC scaffolds with greater specificity and potency against M. tuberculosis.
A new class of Cyclophostin and Cyclipostins (CyC) analogs have been investigated against Mycobacterium tuberculosis H37Rv (M. tb) grown either in broth medium or inside macrophages. Our compounds displayed a diversity of action by acting either on extracellular M. tb bacterial growth only, or both intracellularly on infected macrophages as well as extracellularly on bacterial growth with very low toxicity towards host macrophages. Among the eight potential CyCs identified, CyC 17 exhibited the best extracellular antitubercular activity (MIC50 = 500 nM). This compound was selected and further used in a competitive labelling/enrichment assay against the activity-based probe Desthiobiotin-FP in order to identify its putative target(s). This approach, combined with mass spectrometry, identified 23 potential candidates, most of them being serine or cysteine enzymes involved in M. tb lipid metabolism and/or in cell wall biosynthesis. Among them, Ag85A, CaeA and HsaD, have previously been reported as essential for in vitro growth of M. tb and/or survival and persistence in macrophages. Overall, our findings support the assumption that CyC 17 may thus represent a novel class of multi-target inhibitor leading to the arrest of M. tb growth through a cumulative inhibition of a large number of Ser- and Cys-containing enzymes participating in important physiological processes.
Title: Synthesis and comparison of the biological activity of monocyclic phosphonate, difluorophosphonate and phosphate analogs of the natural AChE inhibitor cyclophostin Martin BP, Vasilieva E, Dupureur CM, Spilling CD Ref: Bioorganic & Medicinal Chemistry, 23:7529, 2015 : PubMed
New monocyclic phosphate, phosphonate and difluorophosphonate analogs of the natural AChE inhibitor cyclophostin were synthesized and their activity toward human AChE examined. Surprisingly, the phosphate, phosphonate, and difluorophosphonate analogs all showed diminished activity when compared with the natural product.
Cyclipostins are bicyclic lipophilic phosphate natural products. We report here that synthesized individual diastereomers of cyclipostins P and R have nanomolar IC50s toward hormone sensitive lipase (HSL). The less potent diastereomers of these compounds have 10-fold weaker IC50s. The monocyclic phosphate analog of cyclipostin P is nearly as potent as the bicyclic natural product. Bicyclic phosphonate analogs of both cyclipostins exhibit IC50s similar to those of the weaker diastereomer phosphates (about 400nM). The monocyclic phosphonate analog of cyclipostin P has similar potency. A series of monocyclic phosphonate analogs in which a hydrophobic tail extends from the lactone side of the ring are considerably poorer inhibitors, with IC50s around 50muM. Finally cyclophostin, a related natural product inhibitor of acetylcholinesterase (AChE) that lacks the hydrocarbon tail of cyclipostins, is not active against HSL. These results indicate a critical SAR for these compounds, the hydrophobic tail. The smaller lactone ring is not critical to activity, a similarity shared with cyclophostin and AChE. The HSL kinetics of inhibition for the cyclipostin P trans diastereomer were examined in detail. The reaction is irreversible with a KI of 40nM and a rate constant for inactivation of 0.2min(-1). These results are similar to those observed for cyclophostin and AChE.
Title: Enantioselective inhibition of microbial lipolytic enzymes by nonracemic monocyclic enolphosphonate analogues of cyclophostin Point V, Malla RK, Carriere F, Canaan S, Spilling CD, Cavalier JF Ref: Journal of Medicinal Chemistry, 56:4393, 2013 : PubMed
Four nonracemic enolphosphonate analogues of Cyclophostin were obtained by asymmetric synthesis, and their absolute configurations at both phosphorus and C-5 carbon chiral centers were unambiguously assigned. The influence of chirality was studied by testing the inhibitory effects of these four stereoisomers toward the lipolytic activity of three microbial lipases: Fusarium solani cutinase, Rv0183, and LipY from Mycobacterium tuberculosis . Cutinase was highly diastereoselective for the (Sp) configuration using (Sc) inhibitors, whereas no obvious stereopreference at phosphorus was observed with (Rc) compounds. Conversely, Rv0183 exhibited strong enantioselective discrimination for (Sp) configuration regardless of the chirality at the asymmetric carbon atom. Lastly, LipY discriminated only the unusual diastereoisomeric configuration (Rc, Rp) leading to the most potent inhibitor. This work, which provides a fundamental premise for the understanding of the stereoselective relationships between nonracemic enolphosphonates and their inhibitory activity, also opens new prospects on the design and synthesis of highly specific enantioselective antimicrobial agents.
A new series of customizable diastereomeric cis- and trans-monocyclic enol-phosphonate analogs to Cyclophostin and Cyclipostins were synthesized. Their potencies and mechanisms of inhibition toward six representative lipolytic enzymes belonging to distinct lipase families were examined. With mammalian gastric and pancreatic lipases no inhibition occurred with any of the compounds tested. Conversely, Fusarium solani Cutinase and lipases from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Rv0183 and LipY) were all fully inactivated. The best inhibitors displayed a cis conformation (H and OMe) and exhibited higher inhibitory activities than the lipase inhibitor Orlistat toward the same enzymes. Our results have revealed that chemical group at the gamma-carbon of the phosphonate ring strongly impacts the inhibitory efficiency, leading to a significant improvement in selectivity toward a target lipase over another. The powerful and selective inhibition of microbial (fungal and mycobacterial) lipases suggests that these seven-membered monocyclic enol-phosphonates should provide useful leads for the development of novel and highly selective antimicrobial agents.
Title: The first total synthesis of (+/-)-cyclophostin and (+/-)-cyclipostin P: inhibitors of the serine hydrolases acetyl cholinesterase and hormone sensitive lipase Malla RK, Bandyopadhyay S, Spilling CD, Dutta S, Dupureur CM Ref: Org Lett, 13:3094, 2011 : PubMed
Cyclophostin, a structurally unique and potent naturally occurring acetyl cholinesterase (AChE) inhibitor, and its unnatural diastereomer were prepared in 6 steps and 15% overall yield from hydroxymethyl butyrolactone. The unnatural diastereomer of cyclophostin was converted into cyclipostin P, a potent naturally occurring hormone sensitive lipase (HSL) inhibitor, using a one pot dealkylation-alkylation process. The inhibition [IC(50)] of human AChE by cyclophostin and its diastereomer are reported, as well as constituent binding (K(I)) and reactivity (k(2)) constants.
Title: Synthesis and kinetic analysis of some phosphonate analogs of cyclophostin as inhibitors of human acetylcholinesterase Dutta S, Malla RK, Bandyopadhyay S, Spilling CD, Dupureur CM Ref: Bioorganic & Medicinal Chemistry, 18:2265, 2010 : PubMed
Two new monocyclic analogs of the natural AChE inhibitor cyclophostin and two exocyclic enol phosphates were synthesized. The potencies and mechanisms of inhibition of the bicyclic and monocyclic enol phosphonates and the exocyclic enol phosphates toward human AChE are examined. One diastereoisomer of the bicyclic phosphonate exhibits an IC(50) of 3 microM. Potency is only preserved when the cyclic enol phosphonate is intact and conjugated to an ester. Kinetic analysis indicates both a binding and a slow inactivation step for all active compounds. Mass spectrometric analysis indicates that the active site Ser is indeed phosphorylated by the bicyclic phosphonate.
Two diastereomers of a phosphonate analog 6 of the AChE inhibitor cyclophostin were synthesized. The substitution reaction of phosphono allylic carbonate 10a with methyl acetoacetate gave the vinyl phosphonate 9a. Attempted hydrogenation/debenzylation gave an unexpected enolether lactone. Alternatively, selective hydrogenation, demethylation, cyclization and debenzylation gave the phosphonate analog of cyclophostin as a separable mixture of diastereomers 6. The trans phosphonate isomer was more active than the cis isomer against AChE from two sources.
